Ranking Chain Thrift Stores From Worst To Best
Leah Mitchell
Updated on October 07, 2026
Goodwill lands in second-place for worst thrifting option. Goodwill is quite affordable, according to their price guide, and often offers great deals on trendy and vintage items. But they too have received some criticism in regards to their company practices. In 2013, Forbes reported on some very concerning exploitative activity going on within the company. Apparently, Goodwill has paid workers in some states as little as 22 cents an hour. It seems as though there might be a reason their prices are so low.
Crossroads Trading has 37 store locations nationwide, which seems small in comparison to the abundance of Salvation Army and Goodwill locations, but they make up for it in quality. Crossroads is definitely spendier than other stores, however, it's still far more affordable than buying the items new. Additionally, the stores only curate quality items that are very on-trend, so there's no endless digging to find something (via The Daily). The company offers their employees a livable wage and benefits, too (via Crossroads Trading). You'd be hard pressed to find a better thrift store, but there's one more you might want to consider.
Buffalo Exchange ranks as the best chain thrift store. The company has 51 locations, which makes it easier to shop, and according to The Daily, like Crossroads Trading boasts affordable prices and curated on-trend clothes. The company also offers a comprehensive benefit plan for all their employees who work just 20 hours or more a week (via Buffalo Exchange).
Next time you're looking for a wardrobe refresh, you know where to head.